Skip to content
18+For adults 18+ only. Sports betting involves risk.

NHL Prediction: New York Islanders vs Columbus Blue Jackets Match Preview

NHL
New York IslandersNew York Islanders
19:00
17 November · New York
Columbus Blue JacketsColumbus Blue Jackets
12.1744%
X4.1223%
22.8633%
Our prediction
Period 1: Both Teams To Score - No 1.39
our estimate 66% · market 66% The bet will be placed 1–3 hours before the match

New York Islanders host Columbus Blue Jackets at UBS Arena in Elmont on November 17 at 19:00 Eastern. New York are ninth in the Eastern Conference with 22 points from 19 games. Columbus are last with 14 points from 18 games.

New York Islanders
New York IslandersLast 5: 2 W, 0 D, 3 L

Islanders: scoring surge meets a home reset

Recent form and venue split

New York followed three defeats with wins over Los Angeles and Anaheim.

Strengths and pressure points

  • New York scored in all five games.

Personnel, goaltending and travel

Mathew Barzal resumed training in a non-contact jersey on November 10. Starting lines, defensive pairings, the starting goalie, save percentages and power-play or penalty-kill rates remain unavailable.

New York return from three California fixtures, with two clear days between the Anaheim game and this home date.

Recent matches
  • Anaheim Ducksaway6:2
  • Los Angeles Kingsaway5:2
  • San Jose Sharksaway2:3
  • New Jersey Devilshome4:5
  • Carolina Hurricaneshome3:5
Columbus Blue Jackets
Columbus Blue JacketsLast 5: 1 W, 0 D, 4 L

Blue Jackets: limited production during the slide

Results and attacking output

Columbus have lost four straight since beating Dallas. Across their last five games, they scored nine goals and conceded 17, averaging 1.8 and 3.4 respectively. Four fixtures were at home; their only road game ended in a 5:2 defeat at Buffalo, leaving too little evidence to establish an away trend.

Where the balance breaks down

  • Columbus scored in all five games but exceeded two goals only once.
  • They conceded at least three goals in each of the four defeats.
  • Three of the five games stayed Under 5.5 goals.

Absences and preparation

Conor Garland is on injured reserve with an upper-body injury, Sean Monahan is ruled out, and Isac Lundestrom's Achilles recovery was expected to take another couple of weeks. Rick Bowness missed the last game through illness, with Don Granato deputising; his return is unconfirmed.

Columbus also last played on November 14 but travel from Ohio rather than California. Confirmed lines, goalie save percentages and special-teams rates remain unavailable.

Recent matches
  • Philadelphia Flyershome3:4
  • Tampa Bay Lightninghome1:3
  • Florida Panthershome1:4
  • Buffalo Sabresaway2:5
  • Dallas Starshome2:1

Head-to-head edge, uneven goal totals

The Islanders won ten of the 15 meetings over five years, though the latest eight were split four apiece. Those eight produced 39 goals, averaging 4.9, with four going Over 5.5. New York won the latest meeting 1:0 and took three of the four home encounters. The head-to-head record favours the hosts but offers no consistent scoring pattern.

New York Islanders wins 10draws 0Columbus Blue Jackets wins 5
  • 22.03.2026New York Islanders1:0Columbus Blue JacketsNHL
  • 28.02.2026Columbus Blue Jackets3:4New York IslandersNHL
  • 28.12.2025Columbus Blue Jackets4:2New York IslandersNHL
  • 02.11.2025New York Islanders3:2Columbus Blue JacketsNHL
  • 17.04.2025Columbus Blue Jackets6:1New York IslandersNHL

Commentary needs a timing check

November 12 criticism of the Islanders for seeking draws questioned DeBoer's approach, but preceded the completion of their two-win sequence on November 14. The claim that Columbus scored five in four games is also incorrect: they scored seven across their latest four results.

Our first-period pick

Our pick is Period 1: Both Teams To Score - No 1.39. The strongest route is Columbus failing to score before the first intermission, rather than both attacks being shut down. According to media reports, Conor Garland and Sean Monahan are unavailable through injury, while Isac Lundestrom is still recovering from an Achilles problem. Those absences reduce the visitors’ attacking options and make an immediate response to an Islanders goal less convincing.

New York conceded just two goals in each of their latest two games, a better defensive platform for a controlled opening. That supports the selection without requiring the hosts to sacrifice their own scoring threat. This is a matchup-based lean, not an established opening-period trend. The projected first-intermission score is 1-0 to the Islanders.

Final verdict

Period 1: Both Teams To Score - No 1.39 targets the visitors’ depleted attack over a limited window. The main risk is an early defensive error: the selection needs only one side to remain scoreless, not a low-scoring full game.

Our prediction
Period 1: Both Teams To Score - No 1.39
Place a bet 18+

FAQ

When does New York Islanders — Columbus Blue Jackets kick off?

The match starts on 17.11.2026 at 19:00 (New York), UBS (Elmont).

What is the prediction for New York Islanders — Columbus Blue Jackets?

Our pick is Period 1: Both Teams To Score - No at 1.39.

What are the teams’ chances?

By market estimate: New York Islanders win — 44%, draw — 23%, Columbus Blue Jackets win — 33%.

Chances by market estimate

New York Islanders44%
Draw23%
Columbus Blue Jackets33%

Team form

New York Islanders
New York IslandersLast 5: 2 W, 0 D, 3 L
  • Anaheim Ducksaway6:2
  • Los Angeles Kingsaway5:2
  • San Jose Sharksaway2:3
  • New Jersey Devilshome4:5
  • Carolina Hurricaneshome3:5
Columbus Blue Jackets
Columbus Blue JacketsLast 5: 1 W, 0 D, 4 L
  • Philadelphia Flyershome3:4
  • Tampa Bay Lightninghome1:3
  • Florida Panthershome1:4
  • Buffalo Sabresaway2:5
  • Dallas Starshome2:1

Standings · Eastern Conference

#TeamPWDLGoalsPts
8New York Rangers21120864:5725
9New York Islanders1970660:5622
10Washington Capitals1880862:6520
15Pittsburgh Penguins20301162:7116
16Columbus Blue Jackets18201145:5814

Head-to-head

New York Islanders wins 10draws 0Columbus Blue Jackets wins 5
  • 22.03.2026New York Islanders1:0Columbus Blue JacketsNHL
  • 28.02.2026Columbus Blue Jackets3:4New York IslandersNHL
  • 28.12.2025Columbus Blue Jackets4:2New York IslandersNHL
  • 02.11.2025New York Islanders3:2Columbus Blue JacketsNHL
  • 17.04.2025Columbus Blue Jackets6:1New York IslandersNHL

About the match

  • 17 November · 19:00 New York
  • Venue: UBS (Elmont)

Odds

Both teams to score
Period 1: Both Teams To Score - No1.39

Odds updated 16.11 19:10

Market preference shifts toward Columbus

New York remain the 1X2 favourites at 43.8%, against 33.2% for Columbus and 23.1% for a regulation draw. Over the past 24 hours, support has shifted from the hosts toward the visitors, while the draw has barely moved. The hosts' probability remains below a majority.

The Over/Under 5.5 market is nearly balanced, with Over at 51%, though movement favours Under. BTTS (both teams to score) stands at 87.7% and has attracted further support. The stronger market preference is for both teams to score, rather than a high combined total.

Our prediction

Market
Period 1: Both Teams To Score - No
Current odds
1.39
Confidence
Our estimate
66%
Market estimate
66%
Status
pending

The bet will be placed 1–3 hours before the match

Place a bet 18+

More predictions for this tournament

Our predictionPeriod 1: Both Teams To Score - No · 1.39
Place a bet 18+